ExtractComments

How do you see the oldest comments on a YouTube video?

YouTube sorts comments two ways, "Top comments" and "Newest first". There is no "oldest first", so the first comments of an old video sit under thousands of newer ones.

The slow way: Newest first, then scroll to the end

Open the Sort by menu above the comments, choose Newest first and scroll down until no more comments load. The last ones are the oldest. It works for a few hundred comments. Past that the page gets slow, and one accidental reload sends you back to the top.

The fast way: read them all once and jump to the last row

ExtractComments asks YouTube for the comments newest first, page after page, without drawing them on the screen, and writes them into an Excel file or a CSV in that same order. It is free on YouTube and has no limit. A video with 10,000 comments takes a few minutes.

  1. Open the video and click the ExtractComments icon.
  2. Press "Collect comments". Leave "Include replies" unticked if you only want the first comments, not the conversations under them.
  3. Press "Download Excel".
  4. Go to the last row (Ctrl+End). That is the oldest comment YouTube still has for the video. Sort the # column from largest to smallest to read them oldest first.

What the date column says

YouTube does not give the exact date of a comment, only "3 years ago" or "2 months ago", and that is what the Date column has. The order is exact even though the dates are not: row 9,000 was written before row 8,999.

Add to Chrome

Questions

Is the last comment in the file really the first one ever written?

It is the oldest one that still exists. Comments that were deleted by their author, removed by the channel or by YouTube are gone and no tool can list them.

Why does the number of rows not match the count above the comments?

The count YouTube shows includes replies and comments it is holding back. With "Include replies" ticked the file usually ends within a few percent of that number.

Does it work on YouTube Shorts?

The extension works on the normal watch page. Open the Short as a normal video by replacing /shorts/ with /watch?v= in its address.

More guides